Skip to main content

Wintersong by S. Jae-Jones - 2.5 Stars

I have finally read Wintersong. I know, I know... it took me forever. I figured that with Shadowsong
out it was about time to get on with it. I am conflicted though... I wanted to love this book so much... but I couldn't. The plot is clever, but it didn't always deliver. So I am going with the 'middle of the road' score: 2.5. Neither good or bad... a book that exists to help one pass time.

The Blurb:
All her life, nineteen-year-old Liesl has heard tales of the beautiful, mysterious Goblin King. He is the Lord of Mischief, the Ruler Underground, and the muse around which her music is composed. Yet, as Liesl helps shoulder the burden of running her family’s inn, her dreams of composition and childish fancies about the Goblin King must be set aside in favor of more practical concerns.

But when her sister Käthe is taken by the goblins, Liesl journeys to their realm to rescue her sister and return her to the world above. The Goblin King agrees to let Käthe go—for a price. The life of a maiden must be given to the land, in accordance with the old laws. A life for a life, he says. Without sacrifice, nothing good can grow. Without death, there can be no rebirth. In exchange for her sister’s freedom, Liesl offers her hand in marriage to the Goblin King. He accepts.

Down in the Underground, Liesl discovers that the Goblin King still inspires her—musically, physically, emotionally. Yet even as her talent blossoms, Liesl’s life is slowly fading away, the price she paid for becoming the Goblin King’s bride. As the two of them grow closer, they must learn just what it is they are each willing to sacrifice: her life, her music, or the end of the world.
 

Things I liked:
- The writing is beautiful. I love the poetic and lyrical feel to it. Not many authors have that gift.
- The world she created was phenomenal. Reminded me of Holly Black's books and her gift for creating disgusting and yet exquisite magical creatures that you can't help but love. I am always fascinated by darker versions of the magical world.
- The Goblin King. His character was easy to understand and eventually easy to love and easy to connect to. There is much about him I still would like to know but the little I do know I love. He lost through the years part of himself to the crown and Elizabeth's music brings his humanity back to the forefront of his mind. His love for her, or more precisely to her soul, was fierce and unshakable. 

Things I did not like:
- The pace. Seriously, the plot moves in slow motion. The whole story could have been told in a book half its size. Some chapters had enough going on to keep me awake, but for the most part it just bored me.
- The romance was off. It didn't even need to be there. The Goblin King did not love her, he loved her music. As musically 'declined' as I am I understood that and appreciated it. So the whole attempt to turn that love into a romantic love between two people fell flat and made little sense. While I appreciate the author tried to make their connection other than physical, she failed. And she failed big.  Elizabeth pretty much wanted to jump on him at all times while he kept saying no. She did not love the Goblin King but her idea of him. And he did not love her, he loved her music. I think he does come to love her, but it is all a tad weird. 
-  It could have been a nice thing that Elizabeth wasn't your usual gorgeous heroine (who thinks she is not gorgeous yet has every male at her feet). But the whole she is ugly thing was overdone. Every other page we got to read how plain she was. And worse than that, she starts to define her worth through him. *kill me now*
- To much music jargon. That is both a negative and a positive. It entirely depends if you are musically inclined or not. I am not, so it was a negative for me. Too much of the story I ended up not truly following.
- The language... There was far too many expressions not translated to English. I can handle that, I speak a few languages myself. But if I want to read a book in another language I go and get a book in another language. It got tired and annoying real fast.

Will I be reading Shadowsong?
No. I have read a few reviews and synopsis and came to the conclusion that chances are I will like Shadowsong even less. The character that saved Wintersong is The Goblin King, and I am told he appears very little in Shadowsong. The second book focuses of Elizabeth and her brother and their relationship is not a great one. I can't handle whiny characters and  that appears to be the case. Which wouldn't surprise me because I thought Elizabeth was pretty whiny on this book already. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Radiant Sin (Dark olympus) by Katee Robert [arc review]

This is sadly, not going to be a very popular review. I adore Katee Robert. But this one just wasn't for me. It wasn't a terrible book or anything like that, it just left me wanting more and very puzzled. Every one of the books in this series follows a certain trope and/or subplot genre. Neon Gods is very much a Greek Mythology retelling;  Electric Idol  has the plus size influencer and the sweet bad boy, it is a very modern contemporary romance;  Wicked Beauty , and my favorite so far has that hunger games/dystopian vibe. Radiant Sin  is a murder mystery. The 'one house'/'one train' style that has always been so popular. Here lies problem number one for me, because I don't like murder mysteries at all. Even on my teen years when I read a lot of mystery it was never those. Problem two- there were way too many characters in that house, and they all got their time on the page making it one very confusing mess. It was very hard to follow at times. I think this

The Book Hater's Book Club by Gretchen Anthony

The Book Hater's Book Club  at first appears to be about a struggling bookstore and its imminent sale. Elliot, the co-owner of Over the Rainbow Bookstore, started  The Book Hater's Book Club , a newsletter of reading recommendations for the self-proclaimed non-readers of the world, because he believed there was a book out there for everyone. Something I wholeheartedly agree with! For years he and Irma have kept the store going and always had a recommendation in hand. When you finish this book, you will have yet another list of books to read.  However, this book is about more than just books and a struggling bookstore. It is also about grief, the price of secrets, and a little more grief.  You see, Elliot is gone, and his grief-ridden business partner has agreed to sell the store to developers. Problem is, she didn't tell that to anyone until the deal was almost done. Which is making her daughters ask questions. Why is she selling? Is it grief alone? Is there something else

Promises and Pomegranates (Monsters & Muses #1) by Sav R. Miller

I was very excited about this read. The reviews are good, the people recommending it were people whose recommendations I have liked in the past. And in the end, at did like this one. But I will confess from the start that Promises and Pomegranates  did not blow me away. Blurb: Elena To most, Kal Anderson is a villain. Harbinger of death, keeper of souls, frequenter of nightmares. Doctor Death. Hades incarnate. They say he stole me. Usurped my fiancé and filled the cracks in my heart with empty promises. Imprinted his crimson fingerprints on my psyche and tried to set me free. They’re not wrong, per se. Except it was my choice to stay. Kal To most, Elena Ricci is an innocent. Goddess of springtime, lover of poetry, angel of my nightmares. Little one. Persephone personified. They say I ruined her. Shattered her virtue and devoured her soul like a succulent pomegranate. Embedded my evil as deep as I could possibly get and tried to set her free. They’re not wrong, per se. Except it was she